Wednesday, October 9, 2013

A reflection of my own experience of culture and identity in relation to education




Leaving behind my humbly small public school (of around 200 students from years kindergarten to year six) to a relatively large, Anglican-based private school was both something I took on with utter nervousness as well as complete thankfulness. When I had received a scholarship to one of the most respected (and as a result, expensive) High School’s in my area, my parents threw a party for me and showered me with kisses and Swarovski treasures. However, what I did not understand at this time was that whilst they were undoubtedly impressed and proud of me for receiving such a reward, this was more of a celebration for my parents, who having both come from public schools in the same area, were determined for me to attend this private school – but only under the condition that it wouldn’t be putting them too out of the pocket.
This subtle snobbery of public vs. private school ideals that my parents exhibited was echoed throughout my time at my new High School. The constant threat of sending me to ‘that dirty public school down the road’ was used whenever I refused to do my homework or failed an exam because of lack of effort. However, this snobbery was not purely based upon my parent’s own views and opinions. Year after year the top private schools in the area would compete in every possible manor to gain a better reputation as well as image, be it our ridiculously expensive (and extensive) uniform’s - including optional school-branded sunglasses, mugs, baseball hats and umbrellas – or pouring the fee’s into area’s of the school that would out-do that of others – such as our agricultural facilities. However, it was the majority of full-fee paying parents that really exhibited this snobbery. If a brand new Audi passed you by in the area, you could be sure to see the School logo plasted on their back window.

It seemed to me that because parents were paying a lot more for their children to attend this school, less focus was made by parents into what the school actually excelled in when compared to others, with the clean-cut image being a main drawing point. This view of a superior reputation as characteristic of Private school students was felt when outside the school, where due to my Uniform, people's perceptions and actions towards me were quite different to my friends from local public schools. When I entered and left stores I was never asked for a bag search, followed suspiciously or watched by store workers like my public school friends often were. Simply because of my uniform and emblem, I was suddenly a more respectable and trustworthy individual, an obvious appeal for parents wishing to send their students to Private schools.

This view is one becoming more popular with parent's today, where University of Sydney lecturer Helen Proctor writes that due to anxieties about unwanted pressures and dangers that teenagers face today, parent's feel that there is a sort of "social cachet attached to some of the [private] schools'', reflecting the perception that paid education would have to have superior benefit's for students, because why else would you pay so much for something that could be virtually free?

Statistically, the shift of students from public schools to private schools is perfectly illustrated in an interactive pie chart on Josephine Tovey's article 'Public primary school numbers up but it tends to get private after that', where it reveals that the 23 percent of students attending Private schools in 1981 has been boosted up to 34 per cent in 2012, public schools revealing their lowest percentage recorded since federation. (Josephine Tovey)

Other such attached reasons for parents choosing private schools would include that, parents who in turn believe that they will always choose the "good" school to send their child too, would give them more control over such educational decisions, and in doing so, would improve their educational outcomes. (Dan Goldhaber, 1999) Such decisions may be influenced by information provided on the Myschools website, where school results and performance are readily available for parents to view and compare.

However, whilst still an important distinguishing factor in a parent's choice of schooling for their child, parent's choosing to send their children to Private schools will almost always believe that such a choice would provide their children with better facilities, a better reputation as well as better results.



Resources: 


 Dan D. Goldhaber (Dec, 1999)'School Choice: An Examination of the Empirical Evidence on Achievement, Parental Decision Making, and Equity' in Educational Researcher, Vol. 28, No. 9, pg. 16-25

No comments:

Post a Comment